Witchy Romance Books with Cozy Fall Vibes
The Spooky Season approaches, which means it’s time to read Witchy Romance Books with Cozy Fall Vibes. These Cozy Witch Romance Books are filled with magical vibes, swoony fall romance, and all the enchanting small-town magic you could want — updated for 2026 with brand new titles!
This post contains Amazon Affiliate links and I may receive a small amount of qualifying purchases.
Witchy Romance Books with Cozy Fall Vibes
My Witchy Romance Ratings
I’ve rated these witchy romances on the three things I look for in a cozy autumn romance:
- 🧙 Witchy Vibes — spells, magical shops, familiars, atmospheric cozy magic
- ❤️ Romance — slow burn, the spark, swoony moments
- 🌶️ Spice — these are cozy romances, so I’m looking for sweet-yet-slightly-spicy
Top New Witchy Romance Books for 2026!
Books & Bewitchment by Isla Jewell
- Inherited magical estate
- Bookshop being built from scratch
- Forbidden romance
- Cockatoo familiar named Doris
- Found family
- Witchy Southern community
- Publication Date: February 2026
Rhea Wolfe inherits her estranged grandmother’s estate in a small mountain town in Arcadia Falls, discovers she’s a witch whose magic is tied to her love of books, and falls for the handsome local handyman, who happens to be the grandson of her grandmother’s sworn enemy in witchcraft.
A Witch in Notting Hill by Alexandra Paige | FREE on Kindle Unlimited
- Witchy bookshop
- London / Notting Hill setting
- Enemies to lovers
- Magic vs. modernity
- FREE on Kindle Unlimited
- Publication Date: August 11, 2026
Rising Hollywood actress and secret witch Willow James hit her magical low point when she turned her manager into a cat. So she journeys to London in search of a rare spell hidden within the famed occult bookstore, Coven & Codex. The last thing she expects? The shop’s brooding, handsome owner, Oliver Hadley, who’d rather avoid magic altogether.
I’m hoping to read this, so stay tuned for my rating!
With All My Haunted Heart by Isabel Sterling
- Sapphic witchy romance
- Gothic atmosphere
- Love and grief
- Haunted — in the best possible way
- Publication date: Sept 9, 2026
Pippa Ainsley needs a side hustle as the local DIY magic shop is cutting into her shop’s business. So when her BFF wants to hire her to check out the paranormal vibes of his bed-and-breakfast, she’s all in. But the hotels attractive co-owner Elle Thompson, wants Pippa to haunt the place.
Grim Tidings (Ghosted #2) by B.K. Borison
- Small-town paranormal
- Series sequel
- Found family
- Slow-burn romance
- Perfect autumn vibes
- Publication Date: September 15, 2026
- My Review of Good Spirits
Darcy (aka the Grim Reaper) is tired of death. So she decides she won’t be dragging her next assignment to the underworld. She’ll be saving him instead. Guardian Angel Gabriel doesn’t tolerate threats to his little corner of the world and magic doesn’t come without consequences.
A Taste of Magic (Scottish Charms #2) by Tricia O’Malley
- Scottish setting
- Series sequel
- A second chance romance with first rate YEARNING
- Cozy and atmospheric
- Publication date: August 25, 2026 by Gallery Books. Thanks to them for my advance copy!
Lyra’s a bit steamed when her spellwork starts misfiring during the filming of Bewitching Bake Off. Even worse? She’s paired with her high school sweetheart turned heartbreak.
But with the cameras rolling, the curse deepening, these old flames will have to cook up more than just a winning pastry to survive.
- 🧙 Witchy Vibes: [5/5] I love Briarhaven, the coven, and all the magic
- ❤️ Romance: [5/5] I love a good second chance at love romance
- 🌶️ Spice: [4/5] Several open door scenes with the right amount of spice
Hearth Witch’s Guide to Spite and Spellwork (Hemlock Saga #2) by Kiri Callaghan
- Witchy detective heroine
- Paranormal atmosphere
- Redemption arc
- Publication Date: October 6, 2026
But after endangering Saga’s life by involving her in a case, Detective Hemlock feels responsible for Saga’s safety. Saga is trying to figure out where she fits in in this new version of normal. When the death of a local witch might be the result of a vicious revenge hex, the enigmatic circumstances and puzzle are too curious to keep them apart.
What Happens at Nightfall by Lauren Willig
- Prickly single dad
- Headstrong single woman
- Set in a historical cemetery
- Spooky Gothic vibes
- Slow burn romance
- Publication Date: October 6, 2026
Jess tags along on a “haunted cemetery” tour hosted by her BFF and comes across a terrified young boy. She walks him back to the cottage he shares with his older sister and dad, Adam, he cemetery arborist. Can Adam and Jess protect his family from a malevolent spirit all while slowly falling for each other?
- 🧙 Witchy Vibes: [5/5] A Gothic cemetery? Buffy vibes?
- ❤️ Romance: [4/5] The romance is slow burn but worth the wait
- 🌶️ Spice: [3/5] A sweet story about love after loss
Entities to Lovers by Mallory Marlowe
- Paranormal romance
- Enemies to lovers
- Peak spooky season energy
- Publication date: October 13, 2026
Rory conducts psychic readings at Ye Olde Spirit Shop and nights haunting the streets of Boston as a ghost-tour guide. When co-guiding a tour with Ezra Blackwell, a thorn in Rory’s side, they end up hexed and have to figure out how to undo the magic.
Love You to Death by Jenna Levine
- Grim reaper love interest
- She dies + gets 6 weeks back
- Paranormal romance with dark humor
- Publicaton Date: October 13, 2026
When Lucy McKenzie gets hit by a bus and dies, a jaded grim reaper named Daniel convinces the Agency to give her six more weeks of life. What neither expected was to fall in love.
Thanks to Berkley for the advance copy!
Witches of Questionable Intent (Books of Dubious Origin #2) by Jenn McKinlay
- Magical bookshop
- Witchy cozy mystery adjacent
- Series sequel
- Found community
- Publication date: November 6, 2026
Zoe Ziakas works at the Museum of Literature safeguarding a secret collection of enchanted tomes. But when the colleague she’s been crushing on reports that their most volatile acquisition has been stolen, Zoe’s carefully cataloged world unravels.
If you haven’t read Jenn McKinlay’s summer beach read, check out my review of The Summer Share! Read this if you liked: The Spellshop by Sarah Beth Durst.
More 2026 Witchy Reads on My TBR
These are on my radar — I’ll move them up to the featured section if I have time to read and rate them!
The Cinnamon Spellbook Bakery by Ella Cook
- FREE on Kindle Unlimited
- A witch baker whose enchanted recipes attract a very mysterious regular customer. Cozy bakery magic.
Potions & Proposals by Kate Callaghan
- FREE on Kindle Unlimited
- A potion-maker and a skeptic cross paths in the most inconvenient (and magical) way possible.
How (Not) to Renovate a Haunted House by Jenny L. Howe
- A woman inherits a haunted house and recruits a reluctant contractor — the ghosts have opinions about the renovation.
The Blue Moon Cafe & 24-Hour Occult Emporium by Lexie Sharabianlou
- A café for supernatural clientele, a charming late-night regular, and a romance that shouldn’t be possible.
Meet Cute Magic by Morgan Elizabeth
- A cursed witch makes a deal with a cranky ghost: he breaks her curse, and she will help him transition to the living.
To Vex & To Hex by Neena Noone
- Witchy enemies-to-lovers for readers who like their magic with a side of swoony tension.
Best Rated Witchy Romance 2025
Witches Guide to Magical Innkeeping by Sangu Mandanna (2025)
- Magical inn in Lancashire
- Opposites attract
- Talking fox familiar
- Found family
- Grumpy historian love interest
A disgraced witch running a cozy inn full of magical misfits meets a grumpy historian who might be the only one who can help her reclaim her lost power. Charming, warm, and deeply cozy. Sequel to mThe Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches — Mandanna’s own companion novel (start there first!)
Love’s a Witch by Tricia O’Malley (2025)
- Scottish witchy small town
- Enemies to lovers
- Century-old family curse
- Grumpy love interest
A witch returns home to break a centuries-old family curse — and clashes with the grumpy mayor who wants nothing to do with her chaotic magic. Read this if you liked: The Ex Hex by Erin Sterling, Payback’s a Witch by Lana Harper, or The Kiss Curse by Erin Sterling.
Good Spirits by B.K. Borison (2025)
- Small-town paranormal
- Family trauma and the healing power of found family
- Yearning
- Holiday vibes of It’s a Wonderful Life
Harriet, the main character, feels alone and unloved. With her wild hair, her quirky fashion taste, and her rejection of a promising law career, she’s the black sheep of her buttoned-up and emotionally distant family.
Nolan is an Irish fisherman who tragically drowned with his whole life ahead of him. Now he’s a ghost who shows people scenes from their past so they can right wrongs.
- 🧙 Witchy Vibes: [5/5] Okay, they’re actually ghostly vibes, but they’re really good!
- ❤️ Romance: [4/5] There’s a bittersweet edge to this romance, but I didn’t mind it!
- 🌶️ Spice: [5/5] Who knew sex with a ghost could be so hot (or chilling?)
An Ancient Witch’s Guide to Modern Dating by Cecelia Edward (2025)
- Time travel witch (17th century → present)
- Fish out of water
- Dating apps vs. witchcraft
- Sassy talking cat
- Cottagecore vibes
Thorn, a 17th-century witch trying to find her perfect match, gets sent 350 years into the future. Can she survive dating apps? Read this if you liked: The Undertaking of Hart and Mercy by Megan Bannen, or A Witch’s Guide to Fake Dating a Demon by Sarah Hawley.
The Peculiar Gift of July by Ashley Ream (2025)
- Pacific coast small town
- Magical orphan
- Community-centered
- More magic than romance
- Literary cozy
A sweet and magical tale about family and community centered on a magical orphan and a small grocery store. More about found family than traditional romance — but deeply cozy and atmospheric. Read this if you liked: Practical Magic by Alice Hoffman, or Garden Spells by Sarah Addison Allen.
Violet Thistlewaite Is Not a Villain Anymore by Emily Krempholtz
- Villain redemption arc
- Magical flower shop
- Grumpy/sunshine romance
- Found family
- Slow burn
- Sentient (mildly murderous) houseplant
Former dark-sorcerer’s right-hand woman Violet Thistlewaite moves to Dragon’s Rest to start over, opens a flower shop, and must work with her grumpy alchemist neighbor to save the town from a magical plague — while trying to prove a villain can deserve a happy ending. Described as “the sweetest cozy fantasy” with a redemption arc at its heart. Read this if you liked: The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches, The Spellshop by Sarah Beth Durst.
Opposites Attract in Cozy Witch Romance Books
The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches by Sangu Mandanna
- Where: The Nowhere House in Norwich
- What: found family and opposites attract
- Witchy Fall Vibes: a remote and mysterious house, magical potions
- THE Essential Cozy Witch Romance!
A Little Too Familiar by Lish McBride
- What: reluctant roommates.
- Can a wolf and an animal mage ever be friends, let alone find love?
Keeper of Enchanted Rooms by Charlie Holmberg – FREE on Kindle Unlimited
- Where: Whimbrel House, Rhode Island in 1846
- What: A writer meets a woman trained in the management of enchanted houses.
- Witchy Fall Vibes: An evil magician and a haunted house
Entities to Lovers by Mallory Marlowe
- Where: Boston
- What: two tour guides get hexes and have to reverse it
- Witchy fall vibes: a matchmaking ghost, Ye Olde Spirit Shop
Romance Books With Witchy Shopkeepers
Entities to Lovers by Mallory Marlowe
- Where: Boston
- What: two tour guides get hexes and have to reverse it
- Witchy fall vibes: a matchmaking ghost, Ye Olde Spirit Shop
Violet Thistlewaite Is Not a Villain Anymore by Emily Krempholtz
- Where: Dragon’s Rest
- What: A former dark sorcerers assistant moves to a small town to start over as a florist
- Witchy fall vibes: A magical fall town, a hunky alchemist, a talking plant.
With All My Haunted Heart by Isabel Sterling
- Where: small town magic shop
- What: sapphic romance
- Witchy Fall Vibes: B & B, ghost tours
The Spellshop by Sarah Beth Durst
- Where: a remote island
- What: an exiled librarian of spell books flees to her childhood home
- Witchy fall vibes: magical jam.
Crescent Moon Tearoom by Stacey Sivinski
- Where: Chicago
- What: magical triplets
- Witchy fall vibes: a tearoom, secrets, a curse, and reading the future
Rewitched by Lucy Jane Wood
A witchy bookseller might lose her magic forever if she can’t believe in herself.
Witchy Whiskers by Danielle Garrett – FREE on Kindle Unlimited
- Where: Winterspell, a supernatural tourist town
- Witchy Fall Vibes: A magic candle shop, a talking cat, and a handsome stranger
Witchy Romance Retellings
A Witch in Notting Hill by Alexandra Paige
- An actress with magical powers travels to London in search of a rare spell
- Witchy retelling of Notting Hill!
The Undertaking of Hart and Mercy by Megan Bannen
- What: a You’ve Got Mail retelling in a fantasy setting as a magical marshal and a female undertaker carry on an anonymous correspondence
- A witchy You’ve Got Mail retelling!
Potions and Prejudice by Tee Harlowe – FREE on Kindle Unlimited
- Where: Thistlegrove
- What: a witchy retelling of Pride and Prejudice
- Witchy Fall vibes: a traveling apothecary shop
Do you have favorite Witchy Romance books With Cozy Fall Vibes to recommend? Leave your picks in the comments!
Also be sure to check out My Magical Realism Romance List!
